BGVP EST12 and EST8

Sound Analysis – EST8.

You would imagine that EST12 and EST8 being siblings 4 drivers apart would be tuned similarly because of having similar tech, but that is not the case.

In comparison to EST12, EST8 is ‘relatively’ darker, with a ‘relatively’ intimate soundstage and has a peak presence in 1-2kHz range which primarily differentiates it from EST12. What defines it is a balance tilted slightly towards the lower spectrum with bass and lower mids playing a fun role and a signature that is targeted towards an audience that likes a smoother and intimate presentation with an X-factor, which is resolution without overly boosted treble.

EST8 sounds as if you’re listening to the band in a old wooden room with an intimate audience but with a decently wide soundstage. Very earthy and organic. What may sound contrary to the tech used is the treble being rather smooth even though EST8 uses 2 EST drivers which are specifically designed and famous for treble duties.

Switches – EST8’s switches are not as effective as EST12. Most modes besides 000 did not sound as good to me, so I’m going to keep this simple and write the sound analysis based on the 000 combination which is pretty cool by itself.

Volume power – Before starting the sound analysis, I’d like to point out that EST8 needs more volume power than EST12 and sounds best at average to slightly louder volumes. As soon as you reach its sweet spot, it’ll show you what it’s got with full zeal.

  • Bass – EST8 has nice organic and impactful sounding bass. Imagine a nicely aged vintage Gretsch kick drum’s sound. What is cool is that like in EST12, you can precisely hear the boundaries of the room reverb when used in the track, but the feeling of space is different. As I said above, it sounds as if the band is performing in a nice sounding wooden studio room. For example, listen to Niall Horan’s Slow Hands. You can hear the boundaries of the warm drum room in the intro kick drum very accurately. Bass guitar is well present, with sub-bass and mid-bass taking the spotlight more than high-bass. It has good rumble, sustains well but is not as fast as EST12. It gives you the illusion as if a Dynamic Driver is handling bass duties but is actually done by Balanced Armatures.
  • Mids – Lower mids are pretty neutral but a little warmer. It doesn’t make anything muddy, just warm. I hear the curve starting a gradual linear dip around 100-120Hz, dipping lowest at around 700-800Hz, very linearly. This keeps the lower mids decently clean from bloat or mud. Post 800Hz, the curve further rises to make up the peak which lies around 1-2kHz. Technically, big peaks in this area tend to make some instruments sound a little honky and vocals a bit nasally, but luckily, EST8’s peak is not too prominent and vocals sound nice, intimate and very organic (Reference – Chris Cornell’s unplugged version of ‘I Am the Highway’ Live at Queen Elizabeth Theatre). Snare body is portrayed with good authority in songs like Muse’s Panic Station and Karnivool’s Simple Boy. They have the smack and presence but not the peaky upper mids which makes you cringe every time a rock snare is slammed in a song when listening at louder volumes. I hear another small peak around 5kHz but again it’s not too prominent and keeps the organic warm character of the IEM intact, though does help stringed instruments like acoustic guitars and orchestral instruments like horns and strings shine. It also helps drum shells with nice attack.
  • Treble – Treble is again pretty smooth and warm. It feels a bit rolled off in songs which are demanding of the treble sizzle but then also helps make EST8 a very easy listen without tiring one’s ears in long sessions. It is not for people who look for a bright V-shape sound in an IEM or extra clarity with boosted treble. It is more like how old vinyl records sound; sound that is associated with vintage instruments and analog tubes.

But if you are someone that likes extended treble and some exciting sizzle, EST8 is not for you. You should look towards the EST12 instead because that’s the IEM with great balance, clarity and openness throughout the frequency spectrum.

bgvp_est8-1 IEM+Cable

Page 4 – Soundstage/imaging/separation, Comparisons, and Conclusion.

6 thoughts on “BGVP EST12 and EST8

  1. the words about the Est12 give us the taste to hear it and buy it .. I’m a singer, and I’m currently working with Shure 215 and Shure 535 I would like to upgrade for some better things .. the A2t de Audio was first choice then I read the good words about some Chinese company cheaper and with the same quality, some suggest me the S8Pro .. the East12 and the very last Le Rolland ..

    My biggest fear with these IEMs is the fit, the comfort on stage .. and the insulation .. currently with shure I almost -37db while the other companies offer -26 db approx

    do you know the Rolland ..

    is the Est12 better than the Shure 846

    between the 4 ” Rolland – Est12 – S8Pro and Shure 846 ” which in your opinion would be best suited for my work

    sorry for my bad English
    Good continuity

    Like

    1. Hey! EST12 is a great option as an in-ear monitor for concerts. It has good resolution, instrument separation and a signature which is very comfortable to listen to for hours together. What is great is that if you feel universal shells won’t isolate as much, BGVP can make you custom shells with your ear impressions at no extra cost if you order from their BGVP Factory Official Store on AliExpress, whose link I’ve posted in the article above in the disclaimer. Mine are universal shells and I’ll be using them as my IEMs in my concerts too. For me universal shells isolate the noise decently well and you can make it better by using appropriate ear tips that block your ear canal perfectly.

      Fearless S8 series is a very good option too. Great value for money with very nice sound quality; surely better than A2e and Shure SE846 IMO. I have the S8F and IMO it’ll make for a good lively monitor. Also, Fearless can make customs shells too if you like. If budget is a constraint, I can personally recommend S8F (haven’t tried the S8Pro, so can’t speak for it). Fearless Roland is a darker sounding IEM with good resolution. If that is something you like, Roland might work well for you.

      You can also consider ItsFit Labs Fusion which sells for around $950. Good impactful bass, natural mids with sparkle and sizzle in treble. They have extensive experience of making custom shells too. You can get in touch with them via Facebook.

      So there you go, three different price points, $489, $950 and $1428. Let me know if you have any further questions. 🙂

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s